Institutions deciding how to evaluate an asset manager generally look past trailing returns and examine the things that produce returns: the investment philosophy, the decision process, the people, the operational controls, and the cost. A sound evaluation is documented, repeatable, and tied to the role the manager is expected to play in the portfolio. It also continues after the hire.
Key takeaways
- Manager evaluation is a process question before it is a performance question: committees ask whether results came from a repeatable discipline.
- Investment due diligence and operational due diligence are separate exercises, and both matter.
- Fit with the institution’s policy, objectives, and existing managers is as important as the manager’s standalone merits.
- No amount of diligence removes the risk that a manager underperforms expectations, so monitoring and clear review criteria are part of the framework.
Begin with the mandate, not the manager
A search is easier to run when the committee has first defined the job. That means identifying the asset class or strategy, the role it plays in the total portfolio, the benchmark that fairly represents it, the time horizon for judging it, and any constraints set by the investment policy statement.
With the mandate defined, candidates can be compared on the same terms. Without it, committees tend to drift toward whichever firm presents most persuasively.
How to evaluate an asset manager: the investment questions
The investment side of due diligence is often organized around philosophy, process, and people.
Philosophy. A manager should be able to state plainly what it believes about markets and why those beliefs might lead to attractive results over time. The explanation should be specific enough to be tested against the portfolio. A value manager, for example, should hold securities that look like value holdings.
Process. Committees ask how ideas are sourced, how research is conducted, how positions are sized, and what triggers a sale. The aim is to understand whether decisions follow a consistent method or depend on improvisation. Sell discipline and risk controls deserve as much attention as idea generation.
People. Who makes decisions, how long the team has worked together, how they are compensated, and whether they invest alongside clients all bear on alignment. Dependence on one individual is a risk worth identifying, along with the plan for succession.
Reading performance with care
Performance belongs in the review, but in context. Committees commonly examine results across full market cycles, relative to an appropriate benchmark and peer group, and adjusted for the risk taken to achieve them.
The more useful question is why the record looks the way it does. A manager whose style was in favor may show strong numbers that say little about skill, and a disciplined manager whose style was out of favor may show weak numbers for reasons consistent with its stated approach.
Past performance does not indicate future results. Institutions that select managers mainly on trailing returns risk hiring after a strong period and terminating after a weak one.
Operational due diligence
A strategy can be sound while the business around it is fragile. Operational due diligence looks at the firm as an enterprise:
- Regulatory registration, disclosures, and compliance program
- Custody arrangements and independence of service providers
- Trading, allocation, and valuation practices
- Cybersecurity, business continuity, and recordkeeping
- Ownership structure and financial stability of the firm
- Conflicts of interest and how they are managed
Many institutions treat a serious operational weakness as disqualifying regardless of investment merit. Fiduciaries with legal obligations around manager selection should consult their own counsel on what their governing documents and applicable law require.
Fees, terms, and fit
Fees are one of the few certain elements of an investment arrangement. Reviewers consider the management fee schedule, any breakpoints, the vehicle through which the strategy is delivered, liquidity terms, and reporting commitments. The question is whether the total cost is reasonable for the service provided, not simply whether it is the lowest.
Fit is equally practical. A new manager should add something the portfolio lacks, since two managers with similar holdings may increase cost without adding diversification.
Pelican Bay Capital Management builds and actively manages proprietary strategies in-house across fundamental, quantitative, and hybrid disciplines. Institutions conducting a review can find a description of each on our portfolios page, and an overview of the organizations we work with under who we serve.
Limits of the evaluation process
Even a thorough review has blind spots. Qualitative judgments are subjective, teams change, and a manager that passes every test may still deliver disappointing results.
For that reason, knowing how to evaluate an asset manager includes knowing how to monitor one. Committees typically set review criteria in advance, such as changes in key personnel, drift from the stated style, or organizational instability, so that later decisions rest on agreed standards and not on short-term frustration.
Frequently asked questions
How long a track record should a committee require?
There is no universal standard. Many committees prefer a record that spans at least one full market cycle so the strategy can be observed in both favorable and unfavorable conditions.
What is the difference between investment and operational due diligence?
Investment due diligence assesses whether the strategy and team are capable of meeting the mandate. Operational due diligence assesses whether the firm’s controls, compliance, and infrastructure are sound. A manager needs to satisfy both.
When should an institution consider replacing a manager?
Common triggers include departure of key decision-makers, a change in philosophy or process, style drift, or organizational problems. Underperformance alone, especially when it is consistent with the manager’s style being out of favor, is usually treated as a reason for closer review and not automatic termination.
Turning evaluation into an ongoing practice
Learning how to evaluate an asset manager is less about finding a perfect firm than about asking consistent questions, documenting the answers, and revisiting them on a schedule. A defined mandate, separate investment and operational reviews, and agreed monitoring criteria give a committee a defensible record of its reasoning. If your organization is reviewing managers and would like to learn more about our strategies, please contact us.
Disclosure: This material is provided by Pelican Bay Capital Management for informational and educational purposes only. It is general in nature, does not take into account the objectives, financial situation, or needs of any particular investor, and should not be construed as personalized investment advice or as a recommendation or solicitation to buy or sell any security or to adopt any investment strategy. Opinions expressed are those of the firm as of the date of publication and are subject to change without notice. All investing involves risk, including the possible loss of principal, and no investment strategy can guarantee a profit or protect against loss. Diversification and asset allocation do not ensure a profit or protect against loss. Past performance is not indicative of future results. Nothing herein constitutes legal, tax, or accounting advice; please consult your own professional advisors.