The fiduciary duty plan sponsors carry comes down to a few core obligations: act solely in the interest of participants and beneficiaries, act with prudence, diversify plan investments, follow the plan’s governing documents, and monitor those to whom work is delegated. These duties are generally judged by the quality of the decision-making process, not by investment results alone. What follows is a general overview and not legal advice.
Key takeaways
- Fiduciary status typically depends on the functions a person performs, such as exercising discretion over plan assets or administration, and not on a job title.
- The core duties are commonly described as loyalty, prudence, diversification, and adherence to plan documents.
- Delegating to an investment manager or other provider can shift certain responsibilities, but the duty to select and monitor prudently generally remains.
- Documentation is the practical evidence that a prudent process was followed.
Who is a fiduciary
Under the federal framework governing most private-sector retirement plans, commonly known as ERISA, fiduciary status is generally functional. A person or entity that exercises discretionary authority over the management of a plan or its assets, or that provides investment advice for compensation, may be a fiduciary to the extent of that activity.
In practice this often includes the sponsoring employer, members of a plan or investment committee, trustees, and investment managers appointed to run plan assets.
Not every decision about a plan is a fiduciary one. Choices such as establishing or terminating a plan are usually treated as business decisions. Governmental and church plans may fall under different rules. The lines are fact-specific, and sponsors should confirm their own status and obligations with qualified counsel.
The fiduciary duty plan sponsors owe: four core obligations
Loyalty
Fiduciaries are expected to act for the exclusive purpose of providing benefits to participants and beneficiaries and defraying reasonable plan expenses. Decisions that favor the employer, a committee member, or a service provider at participants’ expense conflict with this duty.
Prudence
Fiduciaries are expected to act with the care, skill, and diligence of a knowledgeable person in a similar role. The standard is often described as that of a prudent expert. Where a committee lacks expertise in an area, seeking qualified help is generally part of acting prudently.
Diversification
Plan investments are generally to be diversified to reduce the risk of large losses, unless it is clearly prudent not to do so. What counts as adequate diversification depends on the plan’s facts and circumstances.
Following plan documents
Fiduciaries are expected to administer the plan according to its governing documents, to the extent those documents are consistent with applicable law. This includes any investment policy statement the plan has adopted. A policy that is written and then ignored can create more exposure than having none.
Prudence is a process
A recurring theme in fiduciary governance is that prudence is measured by conduct. A decision that turns out poorly is not automatically imprudent, and a decision that turns out well is not automatically prudent. The question is whether the fiduciaries gathered relevant information, considered alternatives, weighed costs and risks, and reached a reasoned conclusion.
A sound process typically includes:
- A defined committee structure with a charter, regular meetings, and clear authority.
- Written criteria for selecting, monitoring, and replacing investment options and managers.
- Periodic review of plan fees and services for reasonableness in light of what is provided.
- Minutes that record what was reviewed, what was discussed, and why decisions were made.
- Ongoing education for committee members.
Our piece on investment committee practices covers the mechanics of running such a group.
Delegation and the duty to monitor
Many sponsors engage outside professionals: investment advisers, discretionary investment managers, recordkeepers, and others. Depending on how an arrangement is structured, an appointed manager may assume fiduciary responsibility for the investment decisions it makes.
Delegation does not end the sponsor’s role. The appointing fiduciary generally remains responsible for choosing the provider through a prudent process and for reviewing the provider’s work at reasonable intervals. Monitoring commonly covers whether the manager is following its stated approach, how results compare with appropriate benchmarks over meaningful periods, whether fees remain reasonable, and whether there have been changes in personnel or ownership.
Common pitfalls and the limits of process
Several patterns tend to create difficulty for plan fiduciaries:
- Meeting irregularly, or meeting without recording the substance of deliberations.
- Selecting or retaining investments on short-term results alone, without examining process, risk, and cost.
- Allowing fees to go unexamined for long periods.
- Overlooking conflicts of interest, including transactions with parties related to the plan, which are subject to detailed restrictions.
- Adopting policies that the committee does not follow in practice.
A good process has limits. It does not prevent investment losses, and it does not remove the possibility of disputes or regulatory inquiry. Fiduciaries may in some cases face personal liability for breaches. Requirements also differ by plan type and jurisdiction and can change over time, which is why periodic review with legal counsel is a normal part of governance.
Frequently asked questions
Does hiring an investment manager remove a sponsor’s fiduciary responsibility?
Generally not entirely. A properly appointed manager may take on responsibility for its own investment decisions, but the sponsor typically retains the duty to select that manager prudently and to monitor it. The allocation of responsibility depends on the plan documents and agreements, which counsel should review.
Are fiduciaries judged on investment performance?
The prevailing standard focuses on the process used to make and review decisions, not on outcomes viewed in hindsight. Results are still relevant, because a prudent process includes evaluating them and acting when warranted.
How often should a plan committee meet?
No single schedule applies to every plan. Many committees meet quarterly, with additional sessions when circumstances call for them. What matters is that reviews are regular, substantive, and documented.
Building a record of prudence
The fiduciary duty plan sponsors accept is demanding, and it is manageable when treated as an ongoing discipline supported by clear documents and qualified advice. Pelican Bay Capital Management works with retirement plans and defined benefit plans among the institutions described on our who we serve page. If your committee would like to discuss how we work with plan fiduciaries, please contact our team.
Disclosure: This material is provided by Pelican Bay Capital Management for informational and educational purposes only. It is general in nature, does not take into account the objectives, financial situation, or needs of any particular investor, and should not be construed as personalized investment advice or as a recommendation or solicitation to buy or sell any security or to adopt any investment strategy. Opinions expressed are those of the firm as of the date of publication and are subject to change without notice. All investing involves risk, including the possible loss of principal, and no investment strategy can guarantee a profit or protect against loss. Diversification and asset allocation do not ensure a profit or protect against loss. Past performance is not indicative of future results. Nothing herein constitutes legal, tax, or accounting advice; please consult your own professional advisors.