A concentrated portfolio strategy holds a limited number of positions so that each one has a meaningful effect on results, while a diversified portfolio spreads capital across many holdings so that no single one dominates. Neither is inherently preferable. Concentration raises the influence of each decision, for better and for worse, and diversification dilutes it.
Key takeaways
- Concentration and diversification sit on a spectrum, and the right point depends on the investor’s objectives and the role of the mandate.
- Fewer holdings allow deeper research per position and a portfolio that differs more from its benchmark.
- That difference cuts both ways: concentrated portfolios may experience larger swings and longer periods of lagging an index.
- Diversification reduces company-specific risk but does not remove market risk, and beyond a point it may add little.
What diversification does and does not do
Every stock carries two kinds of risk. One is specific to the company: a failed product, a lawsuit, a management error. The other is common to the market as a whole. Holding many stocks reduces the first kind, because individual misfortunes tend to offset each other. It does nothing about the second.
The reduction in company-specific risk is steep for the first several holdings added and then flattens. Each additional position contributes less risk reduction than the one before it.
There is a cost to continuing past that point. A portfolio with a very large number of holdings begins to resemble the index it is measured against, and an investor paying active fees for index-like exposure may reasonably question the arrangement.
The case for a concentrated portfolio strategy
Managers who run concentrated portfolios generally make three arguments.
The first is about attention. A research team can know a small number of businesses far more thoroughly than a large number. Depth of understanding may improve the quality of each decision and the speed with which problems are recognized.
The second is about selectivity. A manager with room for only a limited number of positions has to choose among its ideas, and a new candidate has to displace an existing holding. That hurdle can impose discipline.
The third is about impact. If a manager has genuine insight into a company, a small position size mutes the benefit. Concentration lets conviction show up in results.
Each argument depends on the manager’s research actually being sound. Concentration amplifies skill where it exists and amplifies error where it does not.
The risks of holding fewer positions
Single-position risk. In a concentrated portfolio, one serious mistake can meaningfully reduce overall value. There are fewer other holdings to absorb it.
Volatility and tracking difference. Returns may diverge sharply from a broad index over months or years. Periods of substantial lag are a normal feature of the approach, not an anomaly, and they test the patience of committees.
Sector and factor exposure. A small number of holdings can leave a portfolio tilted toward certain industries or styles, whether or not the tilt was intended.
Dependence on the manager. The outcome rests heavily on a small number of judgments. Evaluating the process behind those judgments becomes more important.
For these reasons, a concentrated mandate is often one component of a larger, diversified program instead of the whole.
How risk is managed inside a concentrated portfolio
Concentration does not mean indifference to risk. Managers in this style typically rely on a different set of controls than a diversified manager would.
Security-level safeguards come first: balance sheet strength, business durability, and the price paid relative to estimated value. The idea of demanding a discount to allow for error is covered in our article on why purchase price matters.
Portfolio-level limits follow. These may include maximum position sizes, attention to how holdings relate to each other, and care that several positions do not depend on the same underlying driver. Ten companies exposed to one commodity price are, in effect, fewer than ten independent positions.
Where each approach may fit
Diversified equity portfolios, including index-based ones, suit investors who want market-like exposure at low cost with limited deviation from a benchmark. They are often used as the core of an equity allocation.
Concentrated portfolios suit investors who want a distinct source of active return and can tolerate results that look different from the index. They are frequently sized as a complement to a core holding, with the allocation reflecting how much benchmark deviation the committee is prepared to accept.
Our Concentrated Value Portfolio takes the concentrated approach. It holds a limited number of long equity positions in high-quality companies with above-market dividend yields, purchased at a steep discount to our estimate of intrinsic value, with long holding periods and relatively low turnover. We believe quality, income, and a margin of safety are appropriate companions to concentration, though they do not eliminate the risks described above, and the portfolio can lose value.
Frequently asked questions
How many holdings make a portfolio concentrated?
There is no formal threshold. The term generally describes portfolios with far fewer positions than a broad index and with meaningful weight in the largest holdings. What matters more than the count is how much each position can influence results.
Is a concentrated portfolio riskier than a diversified one?
It typically carries more company-specific risk and may be more volatile relative to a benchmark. Whether that makes the total portfolio riskier depends on how the concentrated mandate is sized and what else the investor holds alongside it.
Can an investor use both approaches together?
Yes. Many institutions pair a broadly diversified core with one or more concentrated managers. The combination seeks market exposure from the core and differentiated results from the concentrated holdings, with the understanding that the latter may add or detract.
Sizing conviction to tolerance
Choosing between a diversified approach and a concentrated portfolio strategy is less a matter of which is correct than of how much deviation from the market an investor wants and can hold through. Both have a place, and many portfolios use both. If you would like to discuss how a concentrated mandate might fit alongside your existing allocation, we invite you to contact us.
Disclosure: This material is provided by Pelican Bay Capital Management for informational and educational purposes only. It is general in nature, does not take into account the objectives, financial situation, or needs of any particular investor, and should not be construed as personalized investment advice or as a recommendation or solicitation to buy or sell any security or to adopt any investment strategy. Opinions expressed are those of the firm as of the date of publication and are subject to change without notice. All investing involves risk, including the possible loss of principal, and no investment strategy can guarantee a profit or protect against loss. Diversification and asset allocation do not ensure a profit or protect against loss. Past performance is not indicative of future results. Nothing herein constitutes legal, tax, or accounting advice; please consult your own professional advisors.